Once upon a time (2010), I owned a fantasy team in a league on Yahoo. Jay Cutler was my starting quarterback. I needed something like seven points to win that week, and Cutler and the Bears were playing the Giants on Sunday Night Football.
Cutler was typically good for 15 to 20 points per game, so I should have had this one. Instead, Cutler threw for only 42 yards with an interception and a fumble lost. He was sacked nine times and was injured near the end of the first half. He did not play the rest of the game and finished with -3.32 fantasy points. To my knowledge, it is the only time during the past 18 years of playing fantasy football that I had started a quarterback who finished with negative fantasy points.
Anyway, I originally drafted Tony Romo in one of my fantasy leagues and then drafted Cutler, of all people, as a backup. When Romo went down with an injury, I was somehow able to acquire Carson Palmer, so I have only had to play Cutler once. I cut Romo but picked him up in time to have him on my roster for the playoffs.
My only football-related thanks on Thanksgiving? I did not start Romo against the Panthers. His three-interception dud left him with -1.76 fantasy points before he left the game with another clavicle injury.
It marked the second time in Romo’s career that he ended up with negative fantasy points. The first occurred in 2005, when as a backup, he knelt on the ball twice in a 33-10 win over the Eagles. That gave him -0.2 points, but that hardly counts given that it was his first appearance in an NFL game.
So in 127 career starts, yesterday marked one of the worst performances of his career and easily the worst fantasy performance of his career.
Here’s a summary of five of his worst games (taking into account both on-field performance and fantasy performance). Note that fantasy points are based on standard scoring on NFL.com.
2015: Carolina 33, Dallas 14
11-21, 106 yds., 0 TD, 3 Int.
-1.76 fantasy points
2007: Philadelphia 10, Dallas 6
13-36, 214 yds., 0 TD, 3 Int.
4.06 fantasy points
2008: Philadelphia 44, Dallas 6
21-39, 183 yds., 0 TD, 1 Int.
4.42 fantasy points
2008: Pittsburgh 20, Dallas 13
19-36, 210 yds., 1 TD, 3 Int.
6.0 fantasy points
2009: Denver 17, Dallas 10
25-42, 255 yds., 0 TD, 1 Int.
6.20 fantasy points
To be sure, he had plenty of dishonorable mentions. For example, he played part of the season finale against the Redskins in 2007 in a 27-6 loss. He posted only 1.44 fantasy points. Few games, however, match yesterday’s performance in terms of futility.