Cowboys vs. Bengals, Ficticious Super Bowl XVI

Cowboys vs. Bengals, Ficticious Super Bowl XVI

Consider this: On January 10, 1982, the Cowboys visited Candlestick Park in San Francisco to face the San Francisco 49ers in the NFC Championship Game. The Cowboys took a late 27-21 lead thanks to a 21-yard touchdown pass from Danny White to Doug Cosbie. The defense had to keep Joe Montana and the San Francisco offense out of the end zone to earn the Cowboys their sixth trip to the Super Bowl. The 49ers moved the ball to the six yard line with 58 seconds left. Joe Montana rolled out to his right, but with nobody open, he threw the ball out of the end zone, missing the outstretched arms of receiver Dwight Clark. On fourth down, Montana’s pass was tipped at the line by Ed “Too Tall” Jones, and the Cowboys were on their way to Detroit to face Cincinnati in Super Bowl XVI.

Super Bowl XVI

Super Bowl XVI

Dallas Cowboys vs. Cincinnati Bengals, Super Bowl XVI

Dallas Cowboys vs. Cincinnati Bengals, Super Bowl XVI

This background brings us to this evening’s simulation using What If Sports. What if The Catch had never occurred, and the Cowboys had faced Cincinnati in the Silverdome on January 24, 1982?

In the simulation, Dallas prevailed 27-13. Thanks to a touchdown pass from Danny White to fullback Ron Springs, Dallas jumped out to a 13-0 halftime lead. A second White-to-Springs touchdown extended the lead in the second half to 20-3, and Cincinnati was unable to catch up. The win gave Dallas its third NFL title, and folks generally got off White’s back for not being Roger Staubach.

At least in our fantasy world, that was so.

Danny White

Danny White

If you weren’t aware of it, omnipresent Cris Collinsworth was a rookie with the Bengals in 1981. He gained more than 1,000 yards that season on 67 receptions, but in this simulation, he gained only 43 yards on three catches.

Cris Collinsworth

Cris Collinsworth

Here is the box score from our fantasy game:

Final – 01/24/1982 1st 2nd 3rd 4th Total
1981 Dallas Cowboys 10 3 7 7 27
1981 Cincinnati Bengals 0 0 10 3 13
Scoring Summary
1st Quarter
DAL 9:24 FG Rafael Septien 39 yds. 3-0
DAL 4:22 TD Ron Springs 1 yd. pass from White (Septien kick) 10-0
2nd Quarter
DAL 0:11 FG Rafael Septien 37 yds. 13-0
3rd Quarter
CIN 10:37 FG Jim Breech 21 yds. 13-3
DAL 5:01 TD Ron Springs 4 yd. pass from White (Septien kick) 20-3
CIN 0:45 TD Charles Alexander 9 yd. run (Breech kick) 20-10
4th Quarter
CIN 6:02 FG Jim Breech 23 yds. 20-13
DAL 1:52 TD Tony Dorsett 5 yd. run (Septien kick) 27-13
 

Team Statistics
  1981 Dallas Cowboys 1981 Cincinnati Bengals
First Downs 24 13
– Rushing 14 7
– Passing 10 6
– Penalty 0 0
3rd Down Eff 7/12 4/10
4th Down Eff 0/1 0/1
Rushes-Yards 41-208 29-186
Avg Rush 5.1 6.4
Comp-Att-Int 18-24-0 11-13-0
Passing Yards 181 86
Sacks-Yards 1-5 3-17
Fumbles-Lost 0-0 2-1
Punts-Avg 1-41.0 2-38.0
KR-Avg 4-14.3 6-22.7
PR-Avg 2-9.0 1-12.0
Penalties-Yard 1-3 3-15
Time of Possession 33:11 26:49

1981 Dallas Cowboys Individual Stats   1981 Cincinnati Bengals Individual Stats
Rushing
  Att Yds 20+ L TD
‘81 Tony Dorsett 23 144 2 43 1
‘81 Ron Springs 13 49 0 12 0
‘81 Danny White 5 15 0 16 0
 
Rushing
  Att Yds 20+ L TD
‘81 Pete Johnson 12 124 2 42 0
‘81 Archie Griffin 4 23 0 13 0
‘81 Charles Alexander 8 23 0 9 1
‘81 Ken Anderson 2 11 0 10 0
‘81 Steve Kreider 1 6 0 6 0
‘81 Jim Hargrove 2 -1 0 0 0
Receiving
  Rec Yds 20+ 40+ L TD
‘81 Drew Pearson 4 40 1 0 23 0
‘81 Doug Cosbie 1 35 1 0 35 0
‘81 Tony Hill 2 30 0 0 18 0
‘81 Ron Springs 4 23 0 0 9 2
‘81 Tony Dorsett 3 22 0 0 14 0
‘81 Billy Joe Dupree 2 20 0 0 14 0
‘81 Butch Johnson 2 16 0 0 11 0
 
Receiving
  Rec Yds 20+ 40+ L TD
‘81 Cris Collinsworth 3 43 0 0 17 0
‘81 Dan Ross 4 27 0 0 10 0
‘81 Pete Johnson 2 15 0 0 10 0
‘81 Steve Kreider 1 12 0 0 12 0
‘81 Charles Alexander 1 6 0 0 6 0
Passing
  Comp. Att. Yards TD INT
‘81 Danny White 18 24 186 2 0
 
Passing
  Comp. Att. Yards TD INT
‘81 Ken Anderson 11 13 103 0 0
Defensive
  Tackles Sacks INT
‘81 Ron Fellows 8 0 0
‘81 Michael Downs 8 1 0
‘81 Everson Walls 5 0 0
‘81 Bob Breunig 4 1 0
‘81 Charlie Waters 3 1 0
‘81 D.D. Lewis 3 0 0
‘81 Guy Brown 3 0 0
‘81 Steve Wilson 2 0 0
‘81 Benny Barnes 2 0 0
‘81 Dennis Thurman 1 0 0
 
Defensive
  Tackles Sacks INT
‘81 John Simmons 6 0 0
‘81 Glenn Cameron 6 0 0
‘81 Rick Razzano 5 0 0
‘81 Bo Harris 5 0 0
‘81 Ray Griffin 5 0 0
‘81 Ken Riley 4 0 0
‘81 Tom Dinkel 4 0 0
‘81 Jim Leclair 3 1 0
‘81 Bryan Hicks 3 0 0
‘81 Louis Breeden 3 0 0
‘81 Mike Fuller 2 0 0
‘81 Clarence Chapman 2 0 0
‘81 Reggie Williams 1 0 0
‘81 Bobby Kemp 1 0 0
Field Goals
  Made Missed
‘81 Rafael Septien 39,37 49
 
Field Goals
  Made Missed
‘81 Jim Breech 21,23 48