50 Seasons Series
now browsing by category
Review each year in the history of the Dallas Cowboys, starting with the planning stages in 1959 and through the present day.
We will get to the games of the 1964 regular season tomorrow, but in the meantime, here is a great video focusing on quarterback Don Meredith.
This post is part of the 50 Seasons in 50 Weeks Series.
On January 20, 1964, Dallas Morning News columnist Bud Shrake received a letter from a satirical 20-member organization known as the Chairman of the Greater North Texas Loyal Fans, Boosters, and Season Ticket Holders Committee for Providing the Dallas Cowboys with Sartorial Splendor. The concern of the committee: the original Dallas Cowboys uniform.
Shrake agreed, noting that the uniforms looked like those worn by a high school all-star squad.
Two days later, columnist Sam Blair reported that the Cowboys would do away with their uniforms featuring their “generous assortment of stars on the helmets and jerseys.” Reporter Gary Cartright later referred to features of the original jersey as “little stars and junk.” Head coach Tom Landry, though, said he didn’t mind the old unis and noted that he never saw a game where a uniform won a game.
[Editorial note: this was six years before the Cowboys were forced to wear blue against the Colts in SB V, which began the Curse of the Blue Jerseys. I thus beg to differ with Coach Landry]
About two weeks after the team announced the new uniforms, Shrake offered the following description:
[R]oyal blue jersey with TV numbers on the shoulders, large numbers front and back, and three stripes on each sleeve. The pants are metallic silver, and the socks royal blue with three stripes. The new helmet is to be metallic silver, with either a boot, a TV number, a star, a D, or the CBS-TV eye as the emblem.
Did You Know?
The pictures from 1960 through 1963 make it clear that Dallas wore blue jerseys at home during the first four seasons of the team’s existence.
But did you know why the Cowboys did not wear white? The answer is they couldn’t. The league had rules in place requiring home teams had to wear colored jerseys at home. This rule changed in 1964, which explains why the Cowboys started wearing white.
After the league’s announcement, general manager Tex Schramm noted:
In the past, most visiting teams looked the same to the home crowds. Except for helmets and socks, they’re always in white. Now the hometown fans can see the different colored uniforms from around the league. Of course they’ll miss seeing their own team’s colorful uniforms but fans get accustomed to this.
For more about the evolution of the Dallas uniform, see the following article written by Fred Goodwin in 1994 and posted on CowboyCards.com:
The Dallas Cowboys Uniform: Tracing Its Evolution Through Football Cards
Cowboys Welcome Dial and McDonald
The Cowboys said goodbye to Billy Howton after the 1963 season, but offseason trades brought two former Pro Bowl receivers in Buddy Dial and Tommy McDonald.
Dallas acquired Dial from Pittsburgh by trading the Cowboys’ first-round pick from 1964, Scott Appleton. Appleton later signed with Houston, making this trade look like a steal for the Cowboys. Dial had recorded 1,295 receiving yards in 1963, his best season as a pro.
McDonald had been to five Pro Bowls as a member of the Philadelphia Eagles. He wrote a guest column for Sports Illustrated during the 1964 off-season in a a story featured on the cover of the July 27, 1964 issue. The lengthy piece covered McDonald’s boyhood, college career, and mastery of the art of route-running and pass catching.
A few items related to these trades are worth noting:
McDonald is Wearing the Old Uniform
The new Dallas uniforms were not ready for the July cover shot shown above. McDonald is instead shown wearing the old home uniform of the Cowboys, even though he actually wore the new blue and silver uniforms during his one season with the team. The new uniforms did not arrive until September, just in time for the season opener against St. Louis.
Goodbye to One Troublemaker, but Hello to Another
Baker had been a troublemaker as a member of the Cowboys, and so when Dallas shipped him to Philadelphia in exchange for McDonald, Landry was apparently relieved. Baker played for Philadelphia for six seasons and made two Pro Bowls.
In the book Landry’s Boys, Dial noted that he was a “terrible influence” on Don Meredith, with home Dial shared a room.
Dial’s poor influence may have been more acceptable if he had performed on the field in Dallas. He showed up to camp in ’64 out of shape, and he injured a leg muscle on a pass play during training camp. He barely played during the 1964 season and saw his receiving yards fall from 1,295 in 1963 to 178 in 1964.
Frank Clarke Worries for Nothing
In Landry’s Boys, author Peter Golenbock also wrote that Frank Clarke was concerned with the trades that brought Dial and McDonald to the team. The competition must have done some good, though, for Clarke in 1964 caught a career-high 65 passes, which were 22 more than he caught in 1963.
The Dallas Cowboys have had a number of very good drafts, but few can compare with the 1964 draft. Among the team’s 20 picks, the Cowboys landed three future Hall of Famers in Mel Renfro, Bob Hayes, and Roger Staubach.
Here is a complete list:
|1||Scott Appleton||DT /Texas||Houston,
1964-66; San Diego, 1967-68
|2||Mel Renfro||DB/Oregon||Dallas, 1964-77|
|3||Perry Lee Dunn||RB/Mississippi||Dallas,
1964-65; Atlanta, 1966-68; Baltimore, 1969
|4||Billy Lothridge||DB/Georgia Tech||Dallas, 1964;
Los Angeles, 1965; Atlanta, 1966-71; Miami, 1972
|6||Jim Evans||WR/Texas El-Paso||N.Y. Jets,
|7||Bob Hayes||WR/Florida A&M||Dallas,
1965-74; San Francisco, 1975
|9||Jake Kupp||G/Washington||Dallas 1964-65;
Washington, 1966; Atlanta, 1967; New Orleans, 1967-75
|10||Roger Staubach||QB/Navy||Dallas, 1969-79|
|12||Johnny Norman||E/Northwest State (LA)||n/a|
|13||Jerry Rhome||QB/Tulsa||Dallas 1965-68;
Cleveland, 1969; Houston, 1970; Los Angeles, 1971
|15||Bill Van Burkleo||B/Tulsa||n/a|
|17||Bud Abell||LB/Missouri||Kansas City,
|18||Theophile Viltz||DB/USC||Houston, 1966|
Three other drafts truly great Dallas drafts occurred in 1975, 1989 and 1991, and we will cover each of these in greater depth later. Consider the players that Dallas landed in these drafts:
1964: Mel Renfro (HOF), Bob Hayes (HOF), Roger Staubach (HOF)
1975: Randy White (HOF), Thomas Henderson, Burton Lawless, Bob Breunig, Pat Donovan, Randy Hughes, Mike Hegman, Herbert Scott, Scott Laidlaw
1989: Troy Aikman (HOF), Daryl Johnston, Mark Stepnoski, Tony Tolbert
1991: Russell Maryland, Alvin Harper, Dixon Edwards, Godfrey Miles, Erik Williams, Leon Lett, Larry Brown
Why 1964 might be the greatest [note on 3/1/2009– I made a mistake in my original post. This has been updated]. Only the Pittsburgh Steelers can boast about having more Hall of Famers in one draft (1974, featuring Lynn Swann, Jack Lambert, Jack Ham, and Mike Webster). The Packers had two in 1958 (Jim Taylor and Ray Nitschke), but none of the Packer drafts have resulted in three.
Why one of the other Dallas drafts was better: Among 20 picks for the Cowboys in 1964, nine never played professional football. Of the remaining 11, only Renfro, Staubach, and Hayes ever did anything significant as professionals. By comparison, the 1975 team produced nine starters, while both the 1989 draft and the 1991 draft produced much of the core of the Super Bowl teams of the 1990s.
You can vote in the poll that appears below. If this poll does not display properly, please visit Zoho Polls to place your vote.
My Vote: 1975
The selections of Hayes and Renfro were important for the Cowboys, but the 1964 draft did not have the impact that the other drafts on this list had. The 1975 draft helped the Cowboys to three Super Bowl appearances in the 1970s. The 1989 and 1991 drafts were vital to the Cowboys’ dynasty of the 1990s. Dallas needed more role players than they received from the 1964 draft.
This post is part of the 50 Seasons in 50 Weeks Series.
In December 1963, Gary Cartwright of the Dallas Morning News wrapped up the effect that the Cowboys’ opening game loss to St. Louis had on the Cowboys’ 1963 season:
Thirteen treacherous weeks ago the Cowboys were regarded as sinister figures in the National Football League.
That was on a Saturday afternoon a few hours before opening night and the news stands were splindid with cover stories on the young Emerging Forces of the Eastern Conference, and there was a song on the lips of Dallas and quiver on the lips of its enemies.
A few hours later the Cowboys were regarded about as sinister as Orphan Annie.
So the comment then is a bit dated now, but we get the idea.
End of the Road
Following the 1963 season, the Cowboys said farewell to two of their more significant founding members: quarterback Eddie LeBaron and receiver Billy Howton.
The 5’7″, 165-pound LeBaron lasted 11 years in the NFL. Just weeks after the Cowboys’ final game of the 1963 season, LeBaron accepted an executive position with Nevada Cement Co. He very quickly became an announcer for CBS Sports and much later became the general manager of the Atlanta Falcons.
A few months after announcing his retirement, LeBaron gave kids at a local YMCA some advice on longevity in the professional football:
Keep complimenting the linemen. When they hit you don’t use bad language or look disgusted. Just say, “Nice tackle.”
Howton retired as the NFL leader in receiving yardage with 8,459. The record stood for just three years, however. Raymond Berry broke the mark in 1966. Howton also once held the record for most receiving yards as a rookie with 1,231.
Hello, Blue and Silver
The 1963 season was the final year the Cowboys played with white
helmets and jerseys with blue stars on the shoulders. Beginning with
the 1964 season, the Cowboys started wearing silver helmets and silver
pants. The Cowboys also adopted the practice of wearing white jerseys
This is a picture of the final game the Cowboys played in their old uniforms. This shot shows Don Meredith throwing downfield in the team’s 28-24 win over St. Louis on December 15, 1963. Blocking is #75 Bob Fry. The Cardinal jumping in the air (#84) is Joe Robb.
Don Meredith’s 460 passing yards against San Francisco on November 10, 1963 was just one of the new records the Cowboys established in 1963. Here is a look at the team and individual records as they stood after the 1963 season.
Most Wins: 5 (1962)
Most Losses: 11 (1960)
Fewest Losses: 8 (twice)
Most Points: 398 (1962)
Most Points Allowed: 402 (1962)
Fewest Points Allowed: 369 (1960– 12 games)
Most Yards: 4912 (1962)
Most Yards Allowed: 5325 (1963)
Fewest Yards Allowed: 4372 (1960– 12 games)
Most Passing Yards: 2872 (1962)
Most Passing Yards Allowed: 3674 (1962)
Fewest Passing Yards Allowed: 2130 (1960– 12 games)
Most Rushing Yards: 2040 (1962)
Most Rushing Yards Allowed: 2242 (1960– 12 games)
Fewest Rushing Yards Allowed: 1510 (1962)
Most 1st Downs: 248 (1963)
Most 1st Downs Allowed: 274 (1962)
Fewest 1st Downs Allowed: 216 (1960– 12 games)
Most Turnovers Caused: 43 (1961)
Most Turnovers Allowed: 50 (1960– 12 games)
Fewest Turnovers Allowed: 36 (1962, 1963)
Most Points: 45 (12/2/1962 vs. Cleveland)
Most Points Allowed: 52 (12/9/1962 vs. St. Louis)
Fewest Points Allowed: 0 (10/8/1961 vs. Minnesota)
Most Yards: 532 (11/10/1963/ vs. San Francisco)
Most Yards Allowed: 577 (12/9/1962 vs. St. Louis)
Fewest Yards Allowed: 183 (10/8/1961 vs. Minnesota)
Most Passing Yards: 419 (11/10/1963 vs. San Francisco)
Most Passing Yards Allowed: 437 (11/18/1962 vs. Chicago)
Fewest Passing Yards Allowed: 58 (11/27/1960 vs. Chicago)
Most Rushing Yards: 226 (12/1/1963 vs. N.Y. Giants)
Most Rushing Yards Allowed: 289 (10/22/1961 vs. Philadelphia)
Fewest Rushing Yards Allowed: 40 (9/30/1962 vs. L.A. Rams)
Most Turnovers Caused: 7 (11/3/1963 vs. Washington)
Most Turnovers Allowed: 7 (twice)
Fewest Turnovers Allowed: 0 (10/8/1961 vs. Minnesota)
Most Rushing Yards: 2374 (Don Perkins, 1961-1963)
Most Rushing TDs: 18 (Don Perkins, 1961-1963)
Most Passing Yards: 5331 (Eddie LeBaron, 1960-1963)
Most Passing TDs: 45 (Eddie LeBaron, 1960-1963)
Most Receptions: 161 (Billy Howton, 1960-1963)
Most Receiving Yards: 3085 (Frank Clarke, 1960-1963)
Most Receiving TDs: 36 (Frank Clarke, 1960-1963)
Most Interceptions: 22 (Don Bishop, 1960-1963)
Most Field Goals: 23 (Sam Baker, 1962-1963)
Most Rushing Yards: 945 (Don Perkins, 1962)
Most Rushing TDs: 7 (Don Perkins, 1962, 1963)
Most Passing Yards: 2381 (Don Meredith, 1963)
Most Passing TDs: 17 (Don Meredith, 1963)
Most Receptions: 56 (Billy Howton, 1961)
Most Receiving Yards: 1043 (Frank Clarke, 1962)
Most Receiving TDs: 14 (Frank Clarke, 1962)
Most Interceptions: 25 (Eddie LeBaron, 1960)
Punting Average: 45.4 (Sam Baker, 1962)
Most Field Goals: 14 (Sam Baker, 1962)
Most Rushing Yards: 137 (Don Perkins, 10/28/1962, vs. St. Louis)
Most Passing Yards: 460 (Don Meredith, 11/10/1963 vs. San Francisco)
Most Passing TDs: 5 (Eddie LeBaron, 10/21/1962 vs. Pittsburgh)
Receptions: 11 (Billy Howton, 11/26/1961 vs. Philadelphia)
Receiving Yards: 241 (Frank Clarke, 9/16/1962 vs. Washington)
Interceptions: 2 (several)
Field Goals: 2 (several)
After the Cowboys’ 1-6 start in 1963, nothing was bound to go better. The Cowboys won two of three to open the second half of the season, but three straight losses meant that Dallas finished with a worse record than was the case in 1962.
The second half of the 1963 season was memorable, even if those memories weren’t exactly positive. Don Meredith set the team record for passing yards in a game, though it was in a losing effort. Tom Landry said he considered jumping off the Empire State Building if the Cowboys had lost a week 10 matchup to the Eagles. And the Cowboys played a game two days after the assassination of President John F. Kennedy.
Week 8: Washington 35, Dallas 20
Don Meredith only threw for 153 yards, but four of his 13 completions were touchdown passes, as the Cowboys beat the Redskins 35-20. Former Brown Bobby Mitchell caught five passes for 100 yards, and former Cowboy Fred Dugan caught two touchdowns for Washington. However, Dallas countered with two touchdown receptions each for Frank Clarke and Lee Folkins.
Here’s a trivia question: Can you name the player running the ball in the shot above? He scored one of the Dallas touchdowns against the Redskins.
Here’s another shot showing #40. The player missing the pass was Billy Howton (#81). Frank Clarke (#82) is shown far right.
Week 9: San Francisco 31, Dallas 24
Don Meredith again had a hot hand against the 49ers in week 9, as his three touchdown passes gave Dallas a 21-7 lead. The Cowboys only managed a field goal for the rest of the day, however, as the Cowboys fell, 31-24. Quarterback Lamar McHan threw two touchdown passes, including one to future actor Bernie Casey.
Meredith threw for 460 yards on the day, establishing a team record that still stands today. In fact, Meredith is one of only two quarterbacks in team history (the other is Troy Aikman) to pass for more than 400 yards in a game.
Dallas Morning News: Meredith’s Greatest Day in Vain | Box Score (Pro-Football-Reference)
Week 10: Dallas 27, Philadelphia 20
The Cowboys pulled out to a 17-6 halftime lead at home against the Eagles, then extended that lead to 27-13 in the fourth quarter. However, the Eagles pulled to within a touchdown thanks to quarterback King Hill’s two touchdown passes. Philadelphia recovered an onside kick with 19 seconds left, giving the Eagles another shot. But the Cowboys’ Warren Livingston picked off a pass to end the game.
Tom Landry later said, “Man, if they had come back and tied that game, I would have jumped off the Empire State Building.” That comment, of course, led to the headline: “Cowboy Coach Considers Suicide Leap If Score Tied.”
I didn’t make that up.
Dallas Morning News: Cowboys Outlast Eagles, 27-20 | Box Score (Pro-Football-Reference)
Week 11: Cleveland 27, Dallas 17
In a game that columnist Bud Shrake said should never have been played, the Cowboys traveled to Cleveland to face the Browns two days after John F. Kennedy was shot in Dallas. In fact, while the Cowboys were preparing for the game, they received word that Lee Harvey Oswald had been shot.
The game itself was forgettable. Cleveland led 13-10 at the half and then extended the lead to 27-10 thanks to two fourth quarter touchdowns. Cornell Green returned a fumble for a touchdown to keep the game a little bit closer, but the Dallas offense did not have enough to mount an effective attack.
Week 12: N.Y. Giants 34, Dallas 27
Don Perkins rushed for three first-half touchdowns, giving the Cowboys a 27-14 halftime lead. The Giants, though, caught fire in the second half. Y.A. Tittle threw for one touchdown and rushed for another, as the Cowboys fell to New York, 34-27.
Dallas Morning News: New York Rally Clips Cowboys, 34 to 27 | Box Score (Pro-Football-Reference)
Week 13: Pittsburgh 24, Dallas 19
Don Meredith’s second touchdown run of the day in the third quarter gave the Cowboys a 19-17 lead. The Cowboys held this lead even with 4:30 remaining. At that point, Pittsburgh faced a 4th-and-14 from its own 16 yard line. Dallas looked poised to put the game away, but the Steelers’ Ed Brown threw a 42-yard pass to Red Mack to convert the fourth down play, and a 24-yard touchdown run by Theron Sapp won the game for Pittsburgh.
The loss was the tenth of the season for the Cowboys, which was the most since the team’s inaugural season of 1960.
| Box Score (Pro-Football-Reference)
Week 14: Dallas 28, St. Louis 24
Between 1960 and 1963, the Cowboys had lost six straight matchups against the St. Louis Cardinals. On the final week of the 1963 season, Dallas finally won. Bob Lilly scored his first career touchdown (he had four during his career), which tied the game at 14 at halftime. Although the Cardinals took a 24-14 lead into the fourth quarter, the Cowboys roared back. Don Meredith hit Pettis Norman and Frank Clarke on touchdown passes, which were enough to give Dallas a 28-24 win.
Dallas Morning News: Dallas Thaws Card Deep Freeze, 28-24 | Box Score (Pro-Football-Reference)
Bottom line: I don’t want to hear any more whining from you about what
I write. If you do happen to come up with one, send it here.
Needless to say, Taylor’s statement set off a firestorm in the comments section. One commenter noted:
I’ve seen some writing on this here blog that borders on what most
would consider unprofessional journalism, but this post not only
crosses that line, but fully takes up residence on the wrong side.
There’s a reason “wow” is used at least half a dozen times in the
responses…we certainly don’t expect for one of the DMN Journalists . . . .
[Personally, I still prefer the DMN journalists over those at the Fort Worth Star-Telegram, but the difference is not as significant as it once was. I don’t defer to the opinions of Taylor or Tim Cowlishaw the way I would defer to someone like Frank Luska. But that’s just me.]
In the 50 Seasons Series, we are up to the 1963 season. Midway through that season, Dallas had a record of 1-6, and fans then were no happier then than they are in 2009.
The main columnist for the DMN in 1963 was a writer named Bud Shrake. He was a bit more critical than his predecessor columnist, Charles Burton, and some fans grew a little bit tired of Shrake’s column.
On October 24, 1963, a reader addressed Shrake as “Bud (Excuses) Shrake” and criticized the analysis offered in the Dallas Morning News by both Shrake and head coach Tom Landry.
A second reader rather sarcastically complimented Shrake for upsetting readers.
Mr Shrake: You have a great talent for stirring up your readers, myself included. I nominate you for the greatest non-sport writer of the year.
A third reader made a comparison between Landry and Vince Lombardi, and in the process the reader questioned why sportswriters thought that Landry was a genius.
Just musing over the comparative records of Vince Lombardi’s Green Bay Packers and Tom Landry’s Dallas Cowboys. I may be mistaken in this but I believe Lombardi inherited as horrible mess at Green Bay as Landry did at Dallas at the arrival of his misfits.
My question in this: If Tom Landry, as the majority of sports-writers clamor, is a genius, what-in-‘ell is Vince Lombardi?
So fans in 1963 were not exactly happy either with the team’s head coach or with the columnists who were covering the team at the time. This is, of course, not much different than today, except the language was certainly nicer back then.
Shrake, incidentally, left the DMN after 1963 to join Sports Illustrated. He later wrote several screenplays and biographies, including the biography of Barry Switzer in 1990. There is more at Shrake’s Wikipedia page.
The 1963 season that was supposed to be so promising for the Dallas Cowboys was effectively over after the first four games, each of which resulted in Dallas losses. Dallas had trouble recovering from a 34-7 blowout loss to the Cardinals, and by the end of October, the Cowboys were 1-6.
Week 1: St. Louis 34, Dallas 7
Playing in front of an audience of 36,432 fans, the Cowboys opened the 1963 season in terrible fashion. After taking a 7-0 lead on a touchdown pass from Don Meredith to tight end Pettis Norman, the Cardinals scored 34 unanswered points, including 20 in the second quarter alone. The Cardinals gained 206 yards on the ground against a Dallas defense that was supposed to be much improved.
One of the Dallas Morning News stories that followed: “That Game Needs Forgetting.”
Here are a few pictures from that game that wasn’t forgotten:
Jerry Tubbs (50) and Lee Roy Jordan (55) stop running back Prentice Gautt.
Week 2: Cleveland 41, Dallas 24
Cleveland running back Jim Brown ran all over the Cowboys, gaining 232 yards on 20 carries. Though Dallas hung tough against Cleveland for much of the afternoon, cutting the Cleveland lead to 27-24 in the third quarter, the defense had no answer for Brown. He had touchdown runs of 71 and 62 yards, and the second of his two touchdowns put the game away.
Week 3: Washington 21, Dallas 17
Billy Howton caught a 44-yard touchdown pass from Don Meredith in the third quarter of the Cowboys’ week 3 matchup against Washington, giving Dallas a 17-14 lead. Dallas missed some opportunities later in the game, and the Redskins regained the lead midway through the fourth quarter. Dallas had no answer and lost the game, 21-17.
Howton surpassed Don Hutson as the NFL leader in career receiving yards. His touchdown reception against Washington was one of only three during the 1963 season, which was his last in the NFL.
Week 4: Philadelphia 24, Dallas 21
The Cowboys found themselves down 24-7 in the third quarter thanks to the play of running back Timmy Brown, who scored two first half touchdowns. Eagle quarterback Sonny Jurgensen, who had been very effective against Dallas in 1962, sat out most of this game with an injury. However, backup King Hill filled in just fine, throwing for two touchdowns. Amos Bullocks helped the Cowboys to keep the game close by scoring two touchdowns, but the Eagles were able to kill the clock thanks to their running game.
Week 5: Dallas 17, Detroit 14
Chuck Howley was the hero of the day against the Lions in the Cowboys’ first win of 1963. He picked off two passes, helping the Dallas defense keep Detroit scoreless for the first three quarters of the game. Amos Marsh scored on a 41-yard touchdown run in the fourth quarter, giving Dallas a 17-7 lead. Detroit scored later in the quarter and had the ball twice late the game, but the Cowboys’ defense held strong.
Week 6: New York Giants 37, Dallas 21
Two touchdown passes by Eddie LeBaron helped to give Dallas a 21-17 halftime lead against the Giants, but the Cowboys could not keep up with New York in the second half. Y.A. Tittle (shown in the shot at the top of this post) threw four touchdowns, including two in the second half, as New York pulled away from the Cowboys. Dallas had trouble moving the ball at all in the second half, as LeBaron was hounded by the Giants’ defensive line.
Week 7: Pittsburgh 27, Dallas 21
Three touchdown passes by Don Meredith helped to give Dallas a 21-6 lead in the third quarter. However, Pittsburgh quarterback Ed Brown threw a total of four TD passes, including three to Buddy Dial (who later played for the Cowboys). With 3:50 left in the game, Pittsburgh tight end Red Mack beat Mike Gaechter and Jerry Overton deep, and Brown hit Mack with a pass that sailed 50 yards in the air. Mack ran it in to complete the 85-yard touchdown play, which gave Pittsburgh the win.
Reaction to the Cowboys’ 1-6 Start
As you might expect, fans were not at all happy with the horrible start to the 1963 season. One fan wrote a letter to the editor, introducing is complaint as follows:
It is not bad enough to continue to lose game after game as teh Cowboys have done and will continue to do with a bunch of has-beens and wise guys, plus the world’s worse coaching staff . . .
The second half of the 1963 season was a little bit better, but not by much.
This post is part of the 50 Seasons in 50 Weeks Series.
Imagine if this were the case today: a professional football team with championship aspirations running up 562 yards of offense (289 passing, 273 rushing) against a combination of three semi-pro teams during training camp.
That is what the Cowboys did during training camp in July 1963. Fortunately, the Dallas players got a “real good workout” according to coach Tom Landry. Don Meredith completed 10 of 13 passes for 183 yards. The defensive standout was rookie defensive back Nat Whitmyer, who was later cut and the picked up by the Rams.Dallas won the scrimmage 44-3.
Here is the most obscure trivia I could ever possibly provide on this blog:
The player who kicked the field goal to prevent a Dallas shutout over the three semipro teams was Jack Summers of the Montebello Vikings.
More Notes from the 1963 Training Camp and Preseason
* Third-round draft pick Jim Price (see yesterday’s post) was a huge disappointment and never came close to making the squad. Landry said Price was one of the biggest misses in the draft up to that point. In fact, Landry said he didn’t think Price was trying very hard. Price spent two years in the AFL before his career ended.
* Cornerback Cornell Green game into camp 10 pounds overweight, but Landry liked the way Green looked in camp. Landry still demanded that the second-year player drop from 224 to 215. The Dallas Morning News referred to Green as the “big cat.”
* The 1963 team was clearly Don Meredith’s, even with the return of Eddie LeBaron. The team’s third quarterback was Sonny Gibbs, who had been drafted in the second round of the 1962 draft. Gibbs saw action during the preseason but never played a down during a regular season game for the Cowboys.
The shot below shows the 6’7″ Gibbs standing over the 5’7″ LeBaron during training camp. An apparently unhappy Tom Landry is to the right.
This post is part of the 50 Seasons in 50 Weeks Series.
The Dallas Cowboys made enough forward strides in their first three years as a franchise that Sports Illustrated predicted the Cowboys could win the Eastern Division (hence, the cover in the shot above). Even though the team had made headlines with its offense in 1962, SI’s preseason prediction was based on the team’s improving defense.
The Dallas Cowboys,
in only the fourth year of their life as a professional football team,
should win the Eastern Division championship of the National Football
League–despite the fact that in 1962, with one of the league’s best
offensive teams, they finished fifth.
This seemingly meager accomplishment by the high-scoring Cowboys actually is proof that one of pro football’s soundest and most
intelligently operated franchises is on or ahead of schedule in its
quest for a league championship. In the past the Dallas weakness has been defense. Now that weakness is being corrected, not so
much by reinforcement as by a process of maturing power.
The Cowboys had 15 picks in the 1963 draft, and the first of these yielded a player who eventually made the team’s Ring of Honor. The others, though, were largely forgettable.
|1||Lee Roy Jordan||LB/ Alabama||Dallas Cowboys, 1963-1976|
|3||Jim Price||LB/ Auburn||New York Jets, 1963; Denver
|4||Whaley Hall||T/ Mississippi||n/a|
|7||Marv Clothier||G/ Kansas||n/a|
|10||Rod Scheyer||T/ Washington||n/a|
|11||Ray Schoenke||G/ SMU||Dallas Cowboys, 1963-1964;
Washington Redskins, 1966-1975
|12||Bill Perkins||HB/ Iowa||New York Jets, 1963|
|13||Paul Wicker||T/ Fresno State||n/a|
|14||Lou Cioci||LB/ Boston College||n/a|
|15||Jerrry Overton||DB/ Utah||Dallas Cowboys, 1963|
|16||Dennis Golden||T/ Holy Cross||n/a|
|17||Ernie Parks||G/ McMurry||n/a|
|18||Bill Frank||T/ Colorado||Dallas Cowboys, 1964|
|19||Jim Stiger||HB/ Washington||Dallas Cowboys, 1963-1965;
L.A. Rams, 1965-1967
|20||Tommy Lucas||E/ Texas||n/a|
Much like the 1961 draft that resulted in the selection of Bob Lilly but nobody else of consequence, the 1963 draft would have been a disaster except for the selection of middle linebacker Lee Roy Jordan. The linebacker from Alabama developed into a Pro Bowl player by 1967, and he was a fixture in Dallas for more than a decade.
Of the other players, perhaps the most notable was Ray Schoenke. He spent two seasons in Dallas before suffering an injury that forced him to sit out the 1965 season. He returned in Washington in 1966 and played for the Redskins through the 1975 season. He later became the founding president of the American Hunters and Shooters Association.
My grade: C-
Picking Jordan was a great move, but none of the others panned out.
Players the Cowboys Missed
The 1963 draft was not a great one, though it featured a few players who later made the Hall of Fame. Here are a few of the players the Cowboys could have taken (and you might notice a bit of Balitmore Colts envy here…):
TE John Mackey (2nd round, Baltimore): Mackey played nine seasons for the Colts, along with one in San Diego, and he was named to the Hall of Fame in 1992.
S Jerry Logan (4th round, Baltimore): Logan made three Pro Bowls as a member of the Colts.
WR Willie Richardson (7th round, Baltimore): Richardson was a two-time Pro Bowler in Baltimore.
TE Jackie Smith (10th round, St. Louis): Long before he dropped a certain pass in Super Bowl XIII, Smith could have been a Cowboy had Dallas taken him before Cardinals did in the 10th round of the 1963 draft.
LB Andy Russell (16th round, Pittsburgh): Russell was a seven-time Pro Bowl pick with the Steelers, and he helped lead Pittsburgh to two Super Bowl titles in the 1970s.
Other Personnel Moves
Offensive Line: Two new faces on the team’s offensive line included guard Jim Ray Smith and tackle Ed Nutting. Smith had been an All-Pro with Cleveland, and Dallas acquired him in 1963. However, injuries slowed him down, and he was gone after the 1964 season. Dallas acquired another Cleveland castoff in Nutting in 1962, but an injury kept him out of action. He played in 1963 but then retired after that season.
Linebackers: Chuck Howley moved from the weak-side to strong-side linebacker in 1963, and Jordan stepped in as the new weak-side backer. Former starter Mike Dowdle was traded to San Francisco.
Defensive Backs: Cornell Green was an undrafted rookie in 1962, but he broke into the starting lineup in 1963 at cornerback. Green was an All-American basketball player in college, but he found greater fame as a defensive back with the Cowboys. Another free agent, Warren Livingston, also moved back into the starting lineup in 1963. Mike Gaetcher moved from cornerback to safety.